Be Freaking Awesome Podcast

EP230 Why “Should” Keeps You Stuck, and What to Say Instead

Angela Belford & Sami Kinnison Season 1 Episode 230

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 21:55

Send us Fan Mail

You know the voice. The one that shows up after the fact and tells you exactly what you should have done differently. Should have stayed home. Should have known better. Should have been more patient, more prepared, more together. It doesn't show up to help you. It shows up to grade you on a test you already turned in.

This week Sami and Angela are calling out should and should have, the phrase that sounds like accountability but actually just adds emotional weight to something you can't change. They dig into where the pattern comes from, why it feels so hard to let go of, and what actually happens in your brain when you swap self-judgment for self-compassion. Angela shares the moment she caught herself quoting her own advice back to herself (and didn't even realize it), and Sami gets honest about a Sunday afternoon that ended with her kids on the couch watching Inside Out as punishment. In this episode, we dig into:

  • Permission to stop grading your past self on a test you didn't know you were taking
  • A simple word swap that turns self-criticism into something you can actually use
  • Why wanting something feels lighter in your body than shoulding on yourself
  • The real difference between owning a mistake and shaming yourself for it
  • How mental rehearsal (yes, the free throw study) actually changes your future patterns

Angela traces the should pattern back to a Facebook memory that stopped her in her tracks, and the two of them talk through why should have is really just judgment wearing a practical-sounding disguise. Sami shares the hindsight-is-2020 version of should (the rained-out concert with her kids) versus the more insidious version, the one with a specific voice attached to it, usually someone else's. And there's a real, tender story from Angela about a friend's health diagnosis and what it looks like to take responsibility without spiraling into self-punishment.

What you'll walk away with is relief. Relief that you don't have to keep replaying yesterday to prove you care about doing better. Relief that wanting to change and criticizing yourself into changing are two completely different things, and only one of them actually works. If you've ever caught yourself mid-should and felt that familiar tightening in your chest, this episode is for you.

Press play now. The should have voice has had the mic long enough. Let's give it something better to say.

Support the show

Sign up at bfreakingawesome.com to get the latest news, insights, and episodes straight to your inbox.

Follow Be Freaking Awesome on Facebook, LinkedIn, Youtube, and Instagram.

Let us know what questions you want to be answered and discussed by emailing us at podcast@bfreakingawesome.com.